|
|
| pkcRAISTLIN |
| quote: | Originally posted by vanilla_cola
Then i'm glad a vast majority of people beleive your opinions blow :tongue2, |
devastated.
| quote: | Originally posted by vanilla_cola
my friend is one of the best composers at melbourne uni and she can't sing to save her life. |
i said like champ. like sing in tune, or work structure and beats/time or even (shock horror) compose music. if you disagree that your average punter is useless, id like an explanation for your typical top 40 song.
i also wonder why people feel the need to defend against one person that happens to dislike one tune. i mean, was someone expecting that this would be the first song in the history of music to be liked by 6 billion people? :conf: |
|
|
| vanilla_cola |
| quote: | Originally posted by pkcRAISTLIN
devastated.
i said like champ. like sing in tune, or work structure and beats/time or even (shock horror) compose music. if you disagree that your average punter is useless, id like an explanation for your typical top 40 song.
i also wonder why people feel the need to defend against one person that happens to dislike one tune. i mean, was someone expecting that this would be the first song in the history of music to be liked by 6 billion people? :conf: |
I'm not going to answer that first part because you're talking :stongue:.
You're offering your opinion without critisism, therefore you're really just talking down the track with no expertise to back it up. Offer usefull advice and tips if you have any, or reasons why the song is not in your taste, otherwise your opinion looks petty. |
|
|
| daveth |
Ummmmm, gonna have to disagree there.
People are entitled to state their opinions, including the fact that they don't think a song is worth raving about, without being obliged to "offer usefull advice and tips" or "expertise to back it up", just as much as the next person who wants to post saying "OMGWTF TUNE!!!" :eek:
Else bystanders would get an unrealistic representation of the general consensus now, wouldn't they? We may as well all love everything... "OMG love that car.... OMG love that jacket... OMG love that tune.. OMFG love PKC's mum" ad nauseum :p |
|
|
| Fpcookie |
| quote: | Originally posted by pkcRAISTLIN
frankly, im of the opinion that if you can't do simple things like sing in tune, your capacity for judging and appreciating music is severely curtailed.
i said like champ. like sing in tune, or work structure and beats/time or even (shock horror) compose music. |
disagree.
though i do agree that i think the tune is average, especially in comparison with some of mikes other work |
|
|
| vanilla_cola |
| quote: | Originally posted by daveth
Ummmmm, gonna have to disagree there.
People are entitled to state their opinions, including the fact that they don't think a song is worth raving about, without being obliged to "offer usefull advice and tips" or "expertise to back it up", just as much as the next person who wants to post saying "OMGWTF TUNE!!!" :eek:
Else bystanders would get an unrealistic representation of the general consensus now, wouldn't they? We may as well all love everything... "OMG love that car.... OMG love that jacket... OMG love that tune.. OMFG love PKC's mum" ad nauseum :p |
I didn't say people are not entitled to state their opinions, isn't that the basis of the western world? I said it appears petty/unsubstantiated if you express your opinion (particularly if negative) without backing it up. I'm not saying this like a nazi declaring you can't say "OMFG TUNEZZ BIATCH!!" cause that's just fun :happy2:.
Isn't pkc's whole arguement based on the idea that peoples opinons of music are worthless unless they poccess a certain level expertise in the area? :rolleyes: |
|
|
CLICK TO RETURN TO TOP OF PAGE
tranceaddict Forums Archive > Local Scene Info / Discussion > Australia
|
