All this shit talking, lets see you post a wip newb.
___________________
Jun-19-2014 14:26
MSZ
godspeed
Registered: Jun 2005
Location: kill me
Pissed I didnt get a mention future ;"(, although I somewhat agree with him. Everyone here is just patting eachother on the back for the most part. Ofcourse this thread is only going to be as good as the people who contribute to it, there seems to be a lack of that around here. Its all good fun if you dont take it too seriously, its really hard to find quality people to bounce shit with that are very knowledgable or have a shit ton of talent, or both. Its the norm in everyday life, shit just get swamped; so I guess its a bit unrealistic to complain.
In b4 people who I've pissed off months ago talk shit to me.
___________________
will suck dick/pussy/growth for some dynaudios
Jun-19-2014 18:00
PaULiN0
Twinkle, Twinkle..
Registered: Mar 2014
Location: Outer Space
Didn't you post something and got an actual response from clay?
___________________
Jun-19-2014 18:19
Storyteller
Supreme tracneaddict
Registered: Feb 2005
Location: The Netherlands
Well since a lot of people here seem to be progressing I think this particular conversation isn't really needed. Also a lot of people here just aren't looking to get burnt down. One step at a time seems to be what most of the people here prefer and I can't blame em. If someome wants brutal honesty they can always ask for it.
If less is more think about how much more more would be.
-Frasier
Jun-19-2014 18:26
MSZ
godspeed
Registered: Jun 2005
Location: kill me
All im saying is, we should lift the DJRYAN ban .
___________________
will suck dick/pussy/growth for some dynaudios
Jun-19-2014 18:56
Seandroid
Supreme tranceaddict
Registered: Oct 2010
Location: Edmonton, Alberta
quote:
Originally posted by MSZ
Pissed I didnt get a mention future ;"(, although I somewhat agree with him. Everyone here is just patting eachother on the back for the most part. Ofcourse this thread is only going to be as good as the people who contribute to it, there seems to be a lack of that around here. Its all good fun if you dont take it too seriously, its really hard to find quality people to bounce shit with that are very knowledgable or have a shit ton of talent, or both. Its the norm in everyday life, shit just get swamped; so I guess its a bit unrealistic to complain.
In b4 people who I've pissed off months ago talk shit to me.
I also agree that a lot of the feedback seems to be done to get it over with so that you can post your own track.
Originally posted by MSZ
Pissed I didnt get a mention future ;"(, although I somewhat agree with him. Everyone here is just patting eachother on the back for the most part. Ofcourse this thread is only going to be as good as the people who contribute to it, there seems to be a lack of that around here. Its all good fun if you dont take it too seriously, its really hard to find quality people to bounce shit with that are very knowledgable or have a shit ton of talent, or both. Its the norm in everyday life, shit just get swamped; so I guess its a bit unrealistic to complain.
In b4 people who I've pissed off months ago talk shit to me.
I knew it you would substantially agree with me. And the patting on the back is exactly what I meant. Such behavior might be comfortable for the insecure, but it doesn't help in any way. I prefer some harsh and elaborated critic rather than "Hey Jim, liking the pluck there" or comments of this kind "maybe you could do this, maybe you could do that"...Like, what the fuck does it mean "maybe"? Do you know what you're talking about or you're just filling the comment section with random words? Maybe means nothing. Is uncertainty that is transmitted at the addressee.
It seems to me like I'm talking common sense here. Would like to hear what Clooney has to say about it.
Jun-19-2014 19:39
MSZ
godspeed
Registered: Jun 2005
Location: kill me
This thread is what it is *insert cliche*
My advice is to friend likeminded people and talk to them on skype or something, you can help eachother and exchange techniques, information and what not. You'll get a much better experience if you're both dedicated.
Im not gonna talk about destructive feedback because im pretty trolly myself.
___________________
will suck dick/pussy/growth for some dynaudios
Jun-19-2014 19:46
future_newbie
Senior tranceaddict
Registered: Apr 2011
Location: Tulaka (Burundi)
quote:
Originally posted by clay
Lol no one ever said to me I was good at theory before thanks. You got it all wrong though, it's my music that rocks. Not the theory I suck at theory. U must too as u seem to be impressed with the basic shit I learned at the age of 10. Again, just check the links I posted, you'll be shocked over its technicality and melodic abstraction and no theory was used in any of them, only pure talent. Yes I rock that much. 90 tracks and a few albums, all released. The fact that you took this little melodic sample as serious says more about you. If you look in music discussion you'll see where it came from. Also I didn't use arpegiator. U can get the project if you like. I plunked in every note. And added awesome lfos.
Bro, just stop it.
Do you know how many requests I got from semi-known labels to release my stuff? Tons. But is not worth it. I mean, for someone like you it might mean something, but I'm aiming higher than putting some average shit on iTunes and rejoice like a virgin who just got her first dick.
Those track are so bad I wonder how you weren't ashamed to post them.
Jun-19-2014 19:57
Andy28
Sandancer
Registered: Jul 2010
Location:
quote:
Originally posted by Seandroid
I also agree that a lot of the feedback seems to be done to get it over with so that you can post your own track.
I think everyone's guilty of this.
However some members have gone that step further to help over pm and even Skype.
It's by no means perfect but the amount of posts made by members it must show it has its place here, yes?
If you're after pro detailed feedback, go and pay a subscription to any of the many providers that's available on the web, but I bet even then you'll not receive your monies worth.